By Mark Frauenfelder at 12:22 pm Fri, May 23, 2008
I thought I saw ZeFrank peek in there from the side at one point…
Hmm… on second look: nope.
I’m sure the BNL video was an influence, but this has a different feel to it. BNL’s video strung together a bunch of clips of YouTube stars lip-syncing to their song; this is more of an ultimate crossover thing. BNL couldn’t’ve shown the Kung Fu Guy ripping off the hood of the Ninja Guy to reveal the Peanut Butter Jelly Time Banana, for instance.
I agree that both the Weezer and BNL’s videos have a different feel to them and both took the idea in a different direction. Regardless of the fact if BNLs had the idea first, IMHO Weezer ran with the idea and made it a 1000 times better. There are so many references and classic Internet videos portrayed; ten times as many as BNL’s video. And besides, I think the Weezer song is just better.
“BNL did this better.”
No, not even close. This was brilliant. An order of magnitude better than the BNL video.
Good god BNL sucks.
I thought “meth minute” did it first, and better, but Weezer is a second.
If I’d have remembered “BNL” meant “bare naked ladies”, I would not have clicked that link. So sneaky!
They have a different feel.
Weezer did it second, and was clearly inspired. That said, its a GIANT improvement on the concept.
The other band just strung together a bunch of lip-syncs… they basically gave the ‘celebs’ a preview of their album, they did their thing, and then strung the video together. It could have been done before or after the track’s release, and without the band.
The weezer approach has everyone star in the video with them… it’s a crossover and meeting of of the celebrities with each other, and the people they mimic. In a way, its kind of postmodern.
Someone want to compile a list of links for The Meth Minute^39 version? It makes me feel less nerdy when I miss more than half the references.
I agree. The Weezer one also recreated the circumstances of the videos themselves, like the stage in evolution of dance or the Miss Teen South Carolina pageant. It was like a Michel Gondry thing.
wait, there are no furries in hell?
The sodomites were quite keen on keeping them, but the simoniacs wouldn’t have it and packed them all off to purgatory.
sorry, I enjoy BNL and weezer, but this guy did it better…
The big list-o-references misses one, which is the scenario for that first webcam setup with the bright window behind the band members. Its a reference to the Pachelbel’s Cannon guitar solo guy…
a nice bit of comment on virtuosity? (intentional or un)
a lot of meemexperiences integrated with a budget here…
Lot’s of subtle tributes going on as well. At 37 seconds a nod to Guy Catches Sunglasses With Face bridges the gap from Mentos Experiment to Fensler G.I. Joe vid. Nice!
Ok yes, BNL did this before but three main points.
1) Weezer is a much better band with a much better song.
2) Weezer has better web celebrities.
3) The overall feel and appearance of Weezer’s video is better.
Bottom line, Weezer probably got the idea from BNL, but they changed it and improved upon the concept.
I thought the video was pretty sub par.
1) Most of these net celebs are old news. Surely there was someone fresher than the Numa Numa guy or Kevin Federline or less worn out than Chris Crocker.
2) I think this is the 3rd/4th video like this where the celebs are shown doing their routine. The video is made assuming we know who these personalities are. The characters have been established, so why not spend the 3 minutes telling a story? Have them team up to fight spambots or something like that.
All furries have to do is say, “Hell hatheth no furry” 10 times in a row as fast as they can and they are exorcised of all furry sin. It’s in the Bible.
1. You’ve highlighted a funny little connection between people using YouTube to gain fifteen minutes of fame and well-established bands producing music videos. This video is fun because we all get to sit around thinking “Hey, I remember that!” Chris Crocker is old? Really? On what time scale?
2. Yeah, that would just be awesome. You should totally get into producing music videos.
BNL did this better.
Oh, Barenaked Ladies can kiss my heinder. This is such a better video and song. I knew Weezer was doing this for the video, but I had no idea it would actually be done *well*. I mean, this is as gimmicky as it gets, but it works. I think it has to do with their using all the original people from the videos. And I also like to think it has something to do with Weezer’s charm.
As for Rivers’ lyrics… well, yeah, they’re not that great. He’s lost that gift of witty, cynical, all-around-amazing lyrics that he had years ago. It’s a shame. But I still love the band.
Also, drumming with lightsabers? AWESOME.
I couldn’t agree more. The whole rest of everything stopped mattering when that part happened. I was giggling with glee…
I didn’t get all of the references, but I think I just had a nerdgasm, anyway.
Weezer kicked my mom off their tour bus once. True Story.
yeah, do you think any of these internet dudes said to weezer: “uh, we’re no Spike Jonze or anything, but we did this video a full YEAR ago for barenaked ladies… you sure you wanna go this route?”
probably not. “money? don’t mind if i do!”
Can we have a counterpart to Godwin’s Law that addresses the “Rick Rolling” phenomena? I’m looking at you, CSTAMAN.
Did they get all those people to do that stuff, or was that just some really good CGI?
Both this one and the BNL one have their good and bad points.
I like the Weezer tune better.
I like this one, but I kind of wish Rivers Cuomo would just get over himself.
“Timbaland knows the way
To reach the top of the charts
Maybe if I work with him
I can perfect the art”?
Rivers, are you being post-ironic, post-post ironic, or are you just really, genuinely this whiny and mopey?
So if you really care, or are really bored, here they are:
Tay Zonday – http://www.youtube.com/user/TayZonday?ob=1
Miss Teen South Carolina – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lj3iNxZ8Dww
Kelly, from the Shoes video – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wCF3ywukQYA
the Will It Blend? blender – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8H29jU8Wrs
Chris Crocker (Leave Britney Alone) – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHmvkRoE …
the dude in Evolution of Dance – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dMH0bHeiRNg
Daft Hands (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2cYWfq- … and Daft Bodies (?) – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5LXNV8Mn …
Charlie the Unicorn (!!!) – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CsGYh8AacgY
the ninja guy – http://youtube.com/watch?v=HFBBh2n2yP0
the Dramatic Look Gopher!! – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y8Kyi0WNg40
it’s peanut butter jelly time! – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s8MDNFaGfT4
the Soulja Boy dance http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ZE2OzguWHo
diet coke and mentos http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hKoB0MHVBvM
lightsaber guys http://youtube.com/watch?v=8NE5elL30w4
t shirts http://youtube.com/watch?v=r6tlw-oPDBM
numa numa kid http://youtube.com/watch?v=60og9gwKh1o&feature=rel …
all your base are belong to us http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qItugh-fFgg
GI Joe PSA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atXIKI2XHj4
I take no credit for compiling this whatsoever. I’m a dork, admittedly, but not totally insane. I stole it from Digg where some other guy stole it from somewhere else, or something.
As much as I’m a big fan of Weezer, I have to agree here – BNL did it first, and I think did it better.
I was just happy to see Charlie the Unicorn get props.
But damn, I really wanted to see a Xeni cameo!
These videos make me absolutely furious. Hell hatheth no furry. I am shaking with anger over how these videos weren’t done right compared to other videos I have seen before anybody else. I can barely even type because I only want to make tight fists and slam my keyboard repeatedly until my Mom calls me up from the basement for dinner. I can hardly even eat my Cheetos as my sticky, orange fingers tremble in anger especially when I realize how OLD all these memes are!1!!
You forgot the tiny dancing horrors.
The anthropomorphic Drama Prairie Dog was upsetting.
I love this video – a great mix of old and new references.
@ Agent 86 #31: wait, there are no furries in hell?
While “hell hath no furry” wins the prize, I have to say:
When there is no more room in Hell, the furry will walk the earth.
I’m kind of surprised Anonymous didn’t show up in this video anywhere. They’d have been more welcome than Rivers Cuomo’s pornstache.
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Submit a tip
The rules you agree to by using this website.
Who will be eaten first?
Jason Weisberger, Publisher
Ken Snider, Sysadmin