Below, Xeni posts about Jamba Juice's outrageous plagiarism of David
Rees's brilliant Get Your War On webcomic. Like many of Rees's fans, I'm
also pissed off by this, but not because of "theft" or "infringement"
-- as Rees himself points out, he uses a bunch of public domain clipart
to make his work; if the roles were reversed (funny webguy uses the same
public domain art as big company to do something that subverts the
original), we'd all be crying fair use, and rightly so.
No, what pisses me off about this is that it's plagiarism. The
unsigned Jamba Juice ads look like they're Rees's work. Even a
sophisticated person who's familiar with both Rees and Jamba might
mistake one for the other.
This may or may not be illegal -- you could argue that Rees has a
common-law trademark claim against Jamba -- but it is certainly
unethical. It's sleazy. It fools the public into thinking that Jamba
Juice has an endorsement that it just doesn't have.
It's easy to get caught up in property talk here and declare that Rees
owns clip art, or clip art with funny speech bubbles, or what-have-you,
but Rees isn't doing that and we shouldn't either. We don't need to
invent exotic new copyright laws that confer ownership over clipart to
condemn Jamba Juice: we can make recourse to the tried-and-true
principle of not tricking people into buying your products and not
plagiarizing other people.
Jamba Juice accused of stealing "Get Your War On" artist's work; GYWO calls for boycott
Fresh Comfy is a Thai scarf-seller whose gauzy chiffon scarves come screened with motifs from literary classics, in a variety of finishes (grey, black, off-white, full color): Anne of Green Gables cover; Harry Potter Marauders’ Map; Map of Middle Earth; Pride and Prejudice cover; the Cheshire Cat; Romeo and Juliet title-page; Sherlock Holmes engravings; Alice […]
Solid Oak Sketches has filed copyright registrations in the tattoo designs that decorate the bodies of some of basketball’s biggest stars (LeBron James, Kobe Bryant, Kenyon Martin, DeAndre Jordan, Eric Bledsoe, etc), and has sued Take-Two Software, maker of NBA 2K16 and other basketball video games, for reproducing tattoos as part of the likenesses of […]
Rheney Williams, a former attorney from Charleston, SC, sells a line of unofficial Disneyland-scented candles themed after the rides, food, and environments of the park.
Real engineers build things. Super cool engineers build things with their hands and fingers, like our engineering forefathers did. No idea where to even begin to do that? This step by step Arduino course is now 92% off and is going to get you up and running, from zero to hero, in no time. So […]
How do Google and YouTube really work? It turns out, Python kind of runs things around those parts. And with this bootcamp, you’ll get whipped into shape and ready to start programming yourself. Whether you’re a Python pro and just want to sharpen your skills, or a total tech newbie with little or no coding […]
Take a deep breath. Now exhale. Wouldn’t that whole breathing thing be a lot better with an amazing vape in your hands? How about a vape that’s specifically engineered and designed for dry leaf and crazy easy to both use and clean? You can save 28% right now when you nab this new FEZ Vaporizer […]