Brooklyn Law School professor Adam J. Kolber's paper "The Experiential Future of the Law" was recently published in the Emory Law Journal
. The paper asks whether (and when) the law will take account of fMRIs and other tools that create quantitative indicators of subjective experience -- that is, what happens when someone claims that they can tell you how much pain they've experienced, and compare that to the pain that someone else in the same situation might experience?
Kolber points out that this question is relevant to crime and punishment, whether you're someone who wants to be sure that the person who committed the crime is punished in a way that's commensurate with the pain he caused; or whether you believe that punishments should be calculated to be bad enough to deter criminals.
Subjective experience is key to both questions, but the legal issues are sure to be thorny. If you're being sued for "pain and suffering" after your negligence caused someone's broken nose, should you be allowed to introduce evidence showing that the victim has an unusually high pain threshold and ask the jury to reduce the damages accordingly? Should state prosecutors be able to show that a convicted criminal has a high tolerance for incarceration and ask for a longer sentence to ensure that he suffers as much as a comparable criminal with a lower tolerance and a shorter sentence?
In this Article, I describe some of the ways in which new technologies are
shifting the way we measure experiences and will continue to do so more
dramatically over the next thirty years. I discuss in general terms how new
technologies may improve our assessments of physical pain, pain relief,
emotional distress, and a variety of psychiatric disorders. I also discuss more
particular applications of such technologies to assess whether: (1) a patient is
in a persistent vegetative state, (2) a placebo treatment relieves pain, (3) an
alleged victim has been abused as a child, (4) an inmate being executed is in
pain, (5) an interrogatee has been tortured, and others.
THE EXPERIENTIAL FUTURE OF THE LAW (PDF)
My central claim is that as new technologies emerge to better reveal
people's experiences, the law ought to do more to take these experiences into
account. In tort and criminal law, we often ignore or downplay the importance
of subjective experience. This is no surprise. During the hundreds of years in
which these bodies of law developed, we had very poor methods of making
inferences about the experiences of others. As we get better at measuring
experiences, however, I make the normative claim that we ought to change
fundamental aspects of the law to take better account of people's experiences.
(Image: fMRI one, a Creative Commons Attribution (2.0) image from twitchcraft's photostream)
Blindsight is a strange phenomenon that sometimes occurs when people have lost sight due to visual cortex damage but still respond to visual stimuli outside of their conscious awareness. New research into blindsight is offering clues, and even more riddles, about how we can “pay attention” outside of what we historically have considered conscious thought. […]
An increasing amount of scientific evidence suggests that animals, from chimpanzees to coyotes to parrots, can suffer from the same mental illnesses as humans. Understanding the biology behind animal depression, OCD, and PTSD could provide insight into why people suffer from mental illness and how these conditions evolved. From BBC Earth: In a 2011 study, […]
Here’s what we know, and what we know we don’t know, and what we don’t know we know, and what we don’t know we don’t know.
SitePoint Premium is the ultimate e-learning library for web developers, designers, and digital professionals. Famous for their web development books written by industry leaders, they’ve expanded their content library to include in-depth video courses and short, handy screencasts partnering with A Book Apart and UX Mastery. Whatever you want to achieve in your web career, […]
Skip the technical jargon and get right to taking amazing, professional-quality photos with this complete training. The Hollywood Art Institute Photography Course includes 22 modules filled with tutorials on how to profit off of your photography, or simply capture your memories in the manner they deserve.Accredited by the Photography Education Accreditation CouncilDive into this 22 […]
Power up your gadgets in the most unexpected places with the extremely compact SolarJuice battery pack. SolarJuice charges up at home like your average battery pack, but also lets you add extra juice on-the-go using its built-in solar panel—so you’ll never be left unplugged from the digital world.4.5 Stars on Amazon!Simultaneously charges 2 devices at […]