Japan: Rare public apology by Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant manager

Discuss

23 Responses to “Japan: Rare public apology by Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant manager”

  1. voiceinthedistance says:

    I was just introduced to a nuclear scientist who moved here to Hawaii the day after the tsunami because she did not want her family near the damaged reactor.

    Not . . . a . . .good . . . sign.

  2. BarBarSeven says:

    Found this appropriate Charles Nelson Reilly image when I did a Google search for “too little, too late.”

  3. jtegnell says:

    I hope he comes back in 10 years and apologizes for all of the deaths of the private contractors working at the plant and all of the cancer suffered by children and infants.

    Those apologies will be ever so helpful.

    • BlueVelvetCrossing says:

      You realize a massive earthquake started all this right?

      • Tommy Timefishblue says:

        You realize there’s more to it than just that, right?

      • BarBarSeven says:

        You realize that the town of Fudai in Japan survived the tsunami because the mayor championed building a 66-foot tall seawall. In contrast the seawall at Fukushima had a 19-foot tall seawall. And the tsunami waves were about 47-feet high.

        http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/05/13/fudai-japan-tsunami-_n_861534.html

        You can plan for disaster, but that costs money.  And TEPCO has a long history of cutting corners. This was the worst example by far. They should be blamed because they put profits above safety.

      • Guest says:

        But you realize a massively undersized flood wall, a lack of redundant systems, and widely criticized design flaws at the nuclear plant came well before the tidal wave, right?

        So, while he is not responsible for the tidal wave, he is speaking for the company, and the company definitely is responsible for not seeing that tidal wave coming decades earlier, profitably “unaware” of their responsibilities.

    • Mark Cresswell says:

      Yes, it is very easy (indeed fashionable) to blame people in a cynical sarcastic way when bad things happen. I doubt the guy knew a massive earthquake followed by a massive tsunami was going to rip a hole in his nuclear plant. I imagine he has family close by too. Accidents have and will always happen – but what more do you want him to do? Anyone reading this could accidentally kill someone today either in a car or with a harsh word. If you consume any electricity and prefer to pay lower bills for it then you are equally culpable – will you apologise? 

      • millie fink says:

        As others above have already pointed out, the company he’s apologizing for is not a mere, hapless victim of an accident. There was much they could have done to make its effects less severe than they have been. That’s what more I wan(ed him and his company to do. And since they haven’t, then I want them to admit to, apologize for, AND compensate for more than “anxiety and inconvenience.”

  4. Yoshida is the guy who disobeyed direct orders from superiors to stop cooling
    with seawater. (The Prime Ministerial liaison heard discussion about the risks of cooling with seawater, and concluded that the general vibe was that the government didn’t think they should do it.)

    If he’d done what he was told it could have been a lot worse.

  5. Guest says:

    That apology and a couple yen will get him a cup of coffee.

  6. Aloisius says:

    Has anyone actually died due to the Fukushima nuclear disaster?

  7. journey46 says:

    “We sincerely apologize…for the anxiety and inconvenience caused by the accident”
    accident ?
    anxiety and inconvenience ?
    legal liability understatement or traditional Japanese politeness ?

  8. jansob says:

    And now he will go on to live a long and comfortable life on his immense pension, which will be paid no matter what. Having “taken responsibility” and bowed deeply, his responsibility is over. In Japan, he has paid the ultimate price. Of course modern Japan is pathetic and stupid (I live here, btw) when it  comes to responsible people facing actual consequences. He will have his luxurious lifestyle, comfort girls and be told by everyone he knows how strong he is and how he must have suffered, and have another drink on the house.

    If he had any balls at all he’d commit suicide. And I’m quite serious…any real Japanese a couple decades ago would have. But merely causing a massive national catastrophe (by not being prepared and by lying about the extent) is now a mere bobble in one’s career. 

    • Dave Jenkins says:

      “comfort girls”?  What year do you think it is, there?

      • jansob says:

        Ok, high-end prostitutes. And you’d be surprised how little has changed her as far as the lifestyles of the elite. This fellow will be living the high life regardless of his “apology”. He’ll still have the call girls and limos and bonuses long after the “liquidators” have been forgotten and thei paperwork lost.

        • Dave Jenkins says:

          Jansob, I doubt he’ll be living the “high life”.  If anything, he’ll continue on with Tepco until he’s 60,  maybe with a window seat somewhere or at least on site until this is over.  Then he’ll retire and go live quietly somewhere, no better and no worse for what he did (and didn’t do).  I don’t think he’s high enough on the food chain to get the big dollars, and he cannot amakudari either: he’s already in the private sector.

          I don’t think companies really pay for nee-chans that much anymore: 20 years of a flat economy will do that.  Tepco still has cash, but it’s saving it for recovery/damage controlo.  Besides, this guy has a public profile now: the last thing they would want is a tabloid scandal.

          • BarBarSeven says:

            Whatever he gets in compensation is a lot more than those who have died or lost their homes or loved ones will ever get. Which is why I don’t care about his feelings or his apology.

            Never apologize for corporations or the people who enable them. They barely know you exist and will never apologize to you unless pressured or legally compelled.

  9. Blaze Curry says:

    Apologizing may not = win, but it certainly does not equal fail.

  10. jphilby says:

    I recommend to the good people of Japan that they refuse his apology and ask him to just go away.

  11. Keith Tyler says:

    Apologizing publicly? Bowing? Next thing you know, he’ll be reaching for the old ceremonial dagger…

Leave a Reply