More cracks in YouTube's takedown process reveal how media giants and corporations get to claim copyright to things they don't own

By at 8:14 am Saturday, Jan 28

An unsigned rap group called After the Smoke couldn't post their song "One in a Million" to YouTube because every time they tried, it generated a YouTube content-match error saying that Universal Music owned their song. It turned out that UMG had laid claim to a leaked video that had a UMG artist performing the unsigned band's track in it, and this effectively gave Universal the power to censor the unsigned band's song.

YouTube's content-matching system has a lot of problems, as archivist Carl Malamud discovered when corporations started to claim that they owned the public domain US government videos he posted, threatening to cost him his YouTube account. And Universal attained notoriety for abusing content match by claiming to own the song that MegaUpload commissioned from major artists criticizing Universal and other rightsholder groups for their copyright stance.

Universal Music May Have Inadvertently Exposed a Flaw in the YouTube Takedown Process

Read more          

Cory Doctorow

Upcoming appearances

* Mar 9, Washington DC, IAPP Global Privacy Summit
* Mar 22, London, The Economist Technology Frontiers
* Mar 24, London, ORGCon

Recent books:
* Context (essays)
* With a Little Help (short stories)
* For the Win (YA novel)
* Makers (adult novel)

Where not otherwise specified, this work is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution. Boing Boing is a trademark of Happy Mutants LLC in the United States and other countries.