Sita Sings the Blues goes CC0

Discuss

19 Responses to “Sita Sings the Blues goes CC0”

  1. I doubt this will make any of the lawyers understand the situation any more.

  2. JoelCave says:

    Great film, made with heart, rather than the latest flavour of the month from Disney/Dreamworks. I applaud Nina and her stance. 

  3. Chentzilla says:

    Will anyone remind me, how was the issue of the songs used in the movie not being in public domain solved?

  4. oasisob1 says:

    Nina Paley is a genius. Be sure to remember this post:
    http://boingboing.net/2005/04/21/excellent-animated-i.html

  5. robcat2075 says:

    Note to all film-makers… you can avoid all this self-created complication by writing new songs for your movie instead of appropriating someone else’s.

    Can’t write songs and don’t have a friend who will do it for you? There are other genres besides “movie musical”.

    • Dewgeist says:

      An artist need struggle against the boundaries of self -this is best realized when the boundaries others place are ignored.

    • jondean says:

      I’m certain that the artist will be glad that these companies fought so hard to protect her rights.
      Oh, wait, she’s been dead 28 years now (23 at the time of “Sita’s” release)? So basically, all profits now merely go to the corporations that own the rights? Maybe the record execs could write their own songs and sell them instead of claiming ownership of someone else’s creative works.

    • TacoChuck says:

       Her collection of the things one must do to properly pay off the myriad parasites living off the body of works of long passed away artists is a work of art in itself.

    • ocker3 says:

       The use of the iconic songs was part of the style/art of the movie, it wouldn’t have worked as well with new pieces.

      • Rev.Veggie.Spam says:

        Polite disagreement here.

        The Drowsy Chaperone is an excellent example of how a work can use entirely new musical pieces to evoke style and art. It can be done. They have awards to prove it. So maybe it could have but really *should* it have to?

        Whether someone *should* have to reinvent cultural wheels because of a broken copyright system is the real, bigger question.

        I offer my respect to Nina for both her talents and her stand against this. Lots of good reasons why to do so have already been pointed out on BoingBoing. Still, I am amazed at the amount of work and what a chunk of her life that it must represent that she’s putting out there under her first creative common license and now updated this license.

        As somebody  who has to work within this current copyright system, I really wish things were different for so many little stupid reasons. There has got to be better ways.

        • ocker3 says:

           She very specifically wanted to use the music of that exact singer in the movie because of the singer’s history and image

  6. theophrastvs says:

    If any artistic or educational grants remain (during these sorry economic times (e.g. National Endowment for the Arts)) then Nina Paley should be jumped to the head of the line.  it would benefit us all.

  7. GouldOldDays says:

    How about this for civil disobedience — sending the lawyers a non-license letter?

    To whom it may concern,

    I have been asked to license rights in my copyrighted work [insert name of work] to [insert what the folks want to do with the work].  I cannot grant that license because there is nothing to license — the requested use of my work falls within the Fair Use doctrine.  I understand that the sending of this letter operates as an equitable estoppel against me or anyone in privity with me ever taking the position in any legal forum that the use described above is not a Fair Use, and therefore precludes me from asserting copyright infringement based on the use described above.

    [closing]

    Even the thickest, dumbest lawyer ought to understand that this letter operates like a license, in terms of giving them the freedom to use the copyrighted work in the way they wanted to.

  8. Arrgh, you had to post the whole movie, didn’t you? How am I supposed to get any work done ;-)

  9. Jorpho says:

    I really ought to get around to watching this sometime.

    Be sure to check out “This Land is Mine” (Ms. Paley’s more recent work) if you haven’t already.
    http://vimeo.com/50531435

    And it’s good to hear Mr. Landreth (that’s they guy who won the Oscar for “Ryan” some years ago) is doing things too.

Leave a Reply