Discuss this post in our forums

52 Responses to “Portlandia just keeps getting better.”

  1. citizen says:

    “The uploader has not made this video available in your country.”

  2. bcsizemo says:

    As a nerd I approve of this message.

  3. Stefan Jones says:

    The standard Comcast cable lineup in Portland doesn’t have IFC. I’m currently savoring Season 2 via Netflix.

    • vonbobo says:

      Savoring? I tore through it like a short stack of marionberry pancakes!

      Only 12 months before I get new stuff!

  4. chgoliz says:

    Personally, not happy with either stereotype of a self-described nerd.  Most of us aren’t either extreme.  It would be a lot easier if we were.

  5. studio 428 says:

    The one where the guy has the recording studio in his house is my favorite Portlandia sketch.  There’s a lot of great musician in-jokes in that one.

    • legsmalone says:

       Ha! I just watched that and chuckled. I’ve also never seen a gold pickguard on an olympic white JM.

  6. Steve says:

    I find it funny that they do this PSA, and the dude ‘Fred’ wears those hipster nerdy glasses.  I mean do they even have lenses in them?

  7. allenmcbride says:

    Great acting by the lead in the PSA skit. But even knowing it’s a joke, it hits too close to home for my comfort. There are actual sexy, socially adept women in this world who are genuinely into comic books, sci-fi, programming, the works. In numbers that are surprising but shouldn’t be. People really do assume they’re not who they say they are, and it’s really not okay.

    • Steve Olsen says:

      Right, but in the proposed scenario it’s obviously not that. I don’t think this is tied to the Internets ongoing conversation about “geek girls.” They don’t, I’m guessing, have a dog in that fight. It’s just a self contained skit. not a sweeping social commentary. Just my guess. I tend to think Portlandia is “sweet” in the classic sense, so to me their skits don’t have bite behind them… just like puppy nibbles, plus they seem to be pretty inclusive and never outright mean.

      I think I replied to the wrong post, my bad.

      • I think it proposes a false dichotomy. “Either you’re an ugly awkward sad male nerd, or you’re a hot fake stupid female ‘nerd’.” In reality there are many shades of gray.

        • Steve Olsen says:

          I won’t argue that it doesn’t, but this doesn’t represent reality. If the sketch was a narrative one, where this guy was talking to that girl would you argue that the character had to be representative of all “nerds”? Where is the line set for this kind of thing? If this were journalism or even a larger piece of work, TV show about this guy/girl then maybe there is an issue? It’s a one off with very specific circumstances. I see the problem but I’m not sure this is material that is meant to throw down in the ongoing argument.

    • Mordicai says:

       Yeah, this is just Fake Geek Girl dressed up in different clothing.  Boo.

      • GlyphGryph says:

        Nah, a Geek is what Nerds aspire to be. No one aspires to be a Nerd, that would just be silly.

        Geeks are different and quirky and have non-mainstream hobbies or lots of trivial specialized knowledge someone else might find interesting. Geeks are perfectly capable of being social and popular, and I agree – defining yourself as a geek is fine. There’s no gatekeepers. It’s a willing association.

        Nerds are different. The world, unlike geek, doesn’t tend to have all those positive fringe attributes that would make someone want to self identify as one. It means irritating, awkward, unattractive, and socially inept. Nerd isn’t one of those things you can self-label as. You are a nerd if /other/ people think you are a nerd.

        You can grow out of being a nerd. Most people want to! You don’t really grow out of being a geek. :P You can hide it, but you don’t really grow out of it.

        (Or at least that’s one particular way to look at it. The difference between the “you aren’t really a geek” and “you aren’t really a nerd” has always felt pretty substantial to me. And I’ve known a few nerd-girls too. I actually thought the nerdy-girl was a pretty common stereotype in media? Certainly when have been appropriate to include one?.)

        • Snig says:

          As a content expert, having been, for decades, considered both nerd and geek before there was an accessible internet, back when it was considered legal to hunt us for sport, the arbitrary distinctions don’t matter.  There will always be someone who will consider you both geek and nerd, as well as someone more hipster than nerd/geek will consider you too normal to be a geek.  Fuck em.  Mean people who have a hobby of disapproving of others, suck.  This goes for nerds, geeks, mundanes, typicals and jocks.  The Fake Geek Girl conversation is dumb, sexist and mean.  As William Shatner once said “Get a life”. 

    • jayson says:

      Agree 100%. It’s a shame they had to perpetuate the “fake geek girl” stereotype. Would have been much better if the “actual nerd” had been a girl, too.

      • Girard says:

        Yeah. Extra damning is that not only is the “fake” nerd at the beginning of the skit a woman, and all of the “authentic” nerds are men, but even the only verbal example he gives of a “fake nerd” is a “sexy girl who went to see the Avengers.”

  8. big ryan says:

    when i was young ‘nerd’ wasn’t something you called someone because of what they liked, but because of what they were like,,, seems these days nerd is more a description of people who really really like something ‘im a music nerd’, ‘im a comic book nerd’, ‘im a _____ nerd” its like the word nerd has replaced the word ‘hobbiest’ or ‘enthusiast’ 

  9. Of_49 says:

    Yeah! Take that, fake geek girls! You certainly do exist! You certainly are threatening! If we don’t successfully marginalize you then we might have to share our stuff with people who like the same stuff we do only they don’t like it *properly*!

  10. Doran says:

    Always a geek. Never a nerd.

    • Christopher says:

      Just out of curiosity, how do you distinguish between nerds and geeks? I’ve always felt there should be a distinction. For instance I’ve always thought of nerds as people who write computer programs while geeks write science fiction novels. Nerds work in IT, geeks work in design or advertising.

      This probably came about in my mind because I’ve always loved things that are often considered nerdy–D&D, science fiction, science fact–but never felt like a genuine nerd because I’m terrible at math. So I preferred to think of myself as a geek. The fact that “geek” was once a term that referred to circus performers who bit the heads off live chickens also appealed to me.

  11. Paul Boudreaux says:

    Sad nerd is sad… Optimist nerd declares victory. Victory!!!! All hail the inter-webs!!!

  12. blueelm says:

    Ok. I didn’t think a fart joke could make me laugh that hard…

    • thatbob says:

      Okay, I read this.  It’s hilarious.  Because the female nerds apparently want the male nerds to stop saying sexist things that marginalize their nerdiness.

      But if the male nerds could understand nuance, socially-appropriate behavior, gender-appropriate communication, or women broadly… then *they wouldn’t be nerds*.

  13. destroy_all_humans says:

    and and and and and and and and and I just wish Fred would stop doing this stuttering joke 10x an episode, my only dislike of an otherwise great show

    • creesto says:

      I’m starting to feel like it might, at least partially, be organic. I am curious how much of their work is improvved

  14. Petzl says:

    Portlandia is a truly transcendent, peerless program.

  15. I’m starting to feel like I need to fill out some sort of form to qualify for nerd-dom. I’ve completed NRD-1 and NRD-5 in triplicate, and I’m just waiting for my witnesses to send back their notarized statements verifying my standing as the absolute least-popular person in my junior high school. 

    • Mordicai says:

      You just have to find the important Gatekeepers & survive the No Win Scenario of Madonna/Whore complex!  Come on, KIRK beat the Kobayashi Maru!

      • GlyphGryph says:

        Yeah, those notarized statements are gold. The Gatekeepers of Nerddom are the “popular” kids. Once they think you’re a nerd, you’re good to go! Everyone knows the NRD forms are just a formality.

    • Girard says:

      After watching this dumb video, I suspect you’ll have to provide your “P3″ form (proof of penis possession) in triplicate to qualify.

  16. Christopher says:

    As much as I’m enjoying season 3 so far nothing has, for me, surpassed Doug and Claire’s Battlestar Galactica obsession.

    But then maybe that’s why I laughed so uncomfortably at the “Nerd PSA”.

  17. Dan Hibiki says:

    Holy crap Matt Berry is in an episode! 

  18. Emo Pinata says:

    This show is still wildly hit or miss with me. While I think a couple skits a season are brilliant, I find just as many grating, and most are just kind of boring. At least the show is mostly new territory.

  19. Hmm, I wonder why no one rushes to discredit attractive and/or outgoing “Fake Geek Guys”…

  20. Navin_Johnson says:

    That first band was The Decemberists, right?