Manning pleads guilty to lesser charges, with 20 years max sentence, but not to aiding enemy

Discuss

16 Responses to “Manning pleads guilty to lesser charges, with 20 years max sentence, but not to aiding enemy”

  1. showme says:

    This is actually not as bad as I had expected. It’s still a travesty, of course, but look who you’re dealing with.

  2. Andrew Singleton says:

    That he had to plead anything at all is a damned shame.

    • jandrese says:

      Good cause or not, violating the terms of your security clearance is something the government cares about.

      • chellberty says:

        No they don’t IE the Bush admin leaked like a sieve.

        • jandrese says:

          There’s a big difference between the White House “leaking” stuff to the press to make themselves look better, and a random guy with a clearance exfiltrating enormous amounts of classified data. 

          • nowimnothing says:

            So that’s what Scooter Libby was doing huh?

          • Daemonworks says:

             True. The latter is the one that should be encouraged.

          • aikimoe says:

            Not legally, there isn’t. When the White House leaks stuff to the press to make themselves look better, they are, by definition, “violating the terms of their security clearance.”

          • jandrese says:

            That depends.  They are the authority on those leaks, so it’s possible that they internally declassified the material before releasing it. 

          • aikimoe says:

            It’s possible, jandrese, but, so far, there’s zero evidence for it.  And if there were, it would simply further illustrate how broken the system for classifying documents is.

  3. Daemonworks says:

    The US government does more every day to aid it’s enemies than Manning could ever have done.

  4. soylent_plaid says:

    Hmmm, so three straight years of torture, abuse and inhuman treatment get you a plea bargain.  See?  Totally worth it guys!  Stop being such bleeding hearts about “human rights” all the time!

  5. Wow. I was just struck how this is EXACTLY like the kangaroo courts and ham-fisted forced confessions that we in the US so roundly condemned. They tortured him* until they got a confession, end of story.

    * Extended solitary confinement is torture: http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1898

Leave a Reply