Discuss this post in our forums

10 Responses to “Copyright enforcement as the New Prohibition: Andy Baio's speech on fair use”

  1. Has anyone else noticed the remarkable frequency with which geeky people in geeky legal trouble who are written up by Boing Boing fold in court, either paying a settlement in civil court or taking a plea bargain in criminal court? Or is this “remarkable frequency” just observer bias on my part? I’m ready to change my mind if reliable data shows I’m just being unfoundedly cynical.

    • Antinous / Moderator says:

      People mostly “fold” in life. Have you noticed how many marriages involve settling?

      • Sure. But how often do we see an example here of someone standing up as a matter of principle and fighting it out to victory or to the bitter end*? I realize people don’t mostly do that in life, either, but you’d think the exceptions–the eventual victories, in particular–would be disproportionately represented here. (I hope they aren’t!)

        *out here with the rest of us meatbots, not in a comment thread

        • Andrew Singleton says:

          Great in principle. The problem is not many people who have millions of dollars are generally willing to help out.

          Not that many people are willing to put forward the time and energy to something even if the lawyers are pro-bono to dedicate themselves to fight this system.

        • Ana KH says:

          You’re disappointed that more people aren’t willing to destitute themselves and ruin the rest of their lives in order to try and win one marginal battle against a massive corporation that, due to its size, cannot be punished by the protracted legal process that crushes the other side, win or lose?

          Please, sir, if you really feel like a lack of hopeless martyrdom exists in this world, step to the front of the line.

          • People have done it. For instance, there is a long history of publishers, mostly smallish, taking on the US government in obscenity and censorship cases, some winning and some losing. But hopeless is the new black.

    • robotnik says:

      “rather than spend a decade and hundreds of thousands of dollars proving … fair use”

  2. anon0mouse says:

    Apparently copyright law does promote creativity…just not in the sciences or useful arts. ¬†We are, however, now in the Golden Age of Litigious Creativity.