Monitoring a computer transistor to understand why a YouTube video is funny
Even though we are learning more and more about what is "under the hood" of human consciousness, it might not tell us what we most want to know about ourselves. It could be like monitoring a transistor in a computer to better understand why a YouTube video was funny. David McRaney explores the dangers of reductionism in the You Are Not So Smart podcast.
You are Not So Smart is hosted by David McRaney, a journalist and self-described psychology nerd. In each episode, David explores cognitive biases and delusions, and is often joined by a guest expert.
"I suppose it is tempting, if the only tool you have is a hammer, to treat everything as if it were a nail."
You've heard the expression before. You've may have, like myself, smugly used it a few times to feel like you made an intelligent point in an office conversation. It's one of those great comebacks that we've decided is ok to use in professional settings like congressional debates and televised political arguments about everything from gun control to foreign policy. But, it might surprise you to learn who wrote it, how young the above quote is, and why it was written in the first place.
The quote comes from psychologist Abraham Maslow, the psychologist most famous for his hierarchy of needs. He was recalling how he had asked scientists of the 1930s to think of things like empathy, compassion, awe, and beauty as aspects of the human mind that could be studied. In his era, it was unclear how you could use the tools of science to do anything other than reduce consciousness to measurable things like neurons and reflexes. Maslow said it was possible, and he blamed skepticism over such pursuits on the culture and tools of the time.
Maslow's famous quote comes after he describes first seeing an automatic car wash, saying how marvelous and complex it seemed, but that he realized that in the end "everything else that got into its clutches was treated as if it were an automobile to be washed." He wrote that if science couldn't process the parts of the mind he was interested in studying he would "either to give up my questions or else to invent new ways of answering them."
That's the topic in this episode of the You Are Not So Smart Podcast - Maslow's Hammer, a plea from humanist psychology to be very careful when reducing human beings to their basic chemistry and not to lose sight of what makes human beings so wonderful.
I first wrote about Maslow's Hammer at Psychology Today, and in this episode I read portions of that essay.
YANSS: RSS |
iTunes | Download this episode | Stitcher | Cookie Recipes | Show Notes
YANSS: RSS | iTunes | Download this episode | Stitcher | Cookie Recipes | Show Notes
[Image: Car Wash, San Bernardino, CACC BY-SA 2.0 Cogart Strangehill - Ext. Car Wash, San Bernardino, CA]
Annoying song stuck in your head? This BrainCraft video explains that listening to it from beginning to end may free you from its burden. It’s a technique based on the Zeigarnik effect, the tendency we have to remember things which are uncompleted. To try it yourself, listen to this first:
Carryl Baldwin, a professor of cognition and applied auditory research, designs and tests sounds for “use as alarms in household, aviation, medical, and automotive settings.” Atlas Obscura explores the art and science of making sounds that convey a spectrum of urgency: One of the main considerations is the annoyance factor. To test for annoyance in […]
Research suggests that people who do nice things for others, often at a cost for themselves, are more sexually attractive. From an evolutionary perspective, this might be because altruism indicates that a potential mate is more cooperative and caring. Evolutionary psychologists Steven Arnocky, at Nipissing University, and Pat Barclay, at the University of Guelph, conducted […]
One of the best ways to progress a career in project management is through earning recognized certifications. These certifications carry significant clout and don’t require expensive tuition or student loans. This Ultimate Project Management Certification Bundle is a great example of an affordable way to get ahead. It includes training for 9 certifications including PMP, […]
There’s nothing quite like the rush of playing against a real human opponent. But from a developer standpoint, creating fun multiplayer experiences is incredibly complex. Fortunately, the Unity3D game engine has made all aspects of game creation, including multiplayer functionality, as accessible as ever.This Unity Course Bundle introduces all of the necessary elements of creating […]
The 2016 World Series game 7 will undoubtedly go down in history as one of the greatest baseball games of all time. With endless suspense, a nefariously-timed rain delay, and extra innings, it reminded over 40 million viewers why they love America’s pastime – and why all bets were truly off in 2016. Savor the […]