As Register Newspapers' high-profile paywall experiment implodes, Clay Shirky offers an acerbic obituary and a dire warning in Nostalgia and Newspapers, which discusses the futility of trying to "save" print, and the news industry's enormous, wishful-thinking blindspot about its own business.
In the same piece where he lauds Kushner, Chittum waits til 2/3rds of the way through to point out that the core of Freedom's strategy "has been unsuccessful most places it's been tried", and buries his most important observation — it will probably fail — at the very end of the piece.
What happened to Chittum and Doctor is endemic to media reporting generally — an industry that prides itself on pitiless public scrutiny of politics and industry has largely lost the will to cover itself with any more skepticism than sports reporters rooting for the home team. (Here's Doctor, writing during the implosion of Freedom's strategy: "The enthusiasm of Kushner and [partner] Spitz is hard to dislike." What's this, a Pharrell profile?)
When you have an audience mostly made up of nostalgists, there's not much market demand for unvarnished truth. This kind of boosterism wouldn't matter so much if it were only reaching weepy journos whose careers started in the Reagan administration. But the toxic runoff from CJR and Nieman's form of unpaid PR is poisoning the minds of 19-year-olds.
We don't have much time left to manage the transition away from print. We are statistically closer to the next recession than to the last one, and another year or two of double-digit ad declines will push many papers into 3-day printing schedules, or bankruptcy, or both. If you want to cry in your beer about the good old days, go ahead. Just stay the hell away from the kids while you're reminiscing; pretending that dumb business models might suddenly start working has crossed over from sentimentality to child abuse.
(Image: HULK SMASH!, Christopher Woo, CC-BY)