US Congress to vote on 'cybersecurity' bills that are basically surveillance bills in disguise
Congress is expected to vote on two 'cybersecurity' bills sometime in the next week that are essentially surveillance bills in disguise. Trevor Timm writes in this editorial, cross-posted on the Freedom of the Press blog, about how they affect journalists and whistleblowers.
Along with dozens of other civil liberties organizations, Freedom of the Press Foundation has signed on to two letters strongly opposing the dangerous “cybersecurity” bills making their way through Congress and expected to be voted on sometime in the next week.
The bills are little more than new surveillance powers wrapped in a cheap disguise, and you can read the full letters that describe the bill’s deficiencies here and here.
If passed, the bills will adversely affect all Americans’ privacy, but they have particularly critical consequences for journalists and whistleblowers, so we wanted to highlight those concerns that the letters did not fully cover.
First, as Politico’s Josh Gerstein reported on Monday, the bills “could create the first brand-new exemption to the Freedom of Information Act in nearly half a century.” The bills aim to allow private companies to share large swaths of private information with the government with no legal process whatsoever, essentially carving a giant hole in the country’s myriad privacy laws. But worse, the proposed FOIA exemption would prevent the public from ever being able to find out what type or amount of information these companies handed over.
Gerstein explains the multiple ways the bills attempts to cut off transparency and accountability:
A bill approved by the Senate Intelligence Committee last month would add a new tenth exemption to FOIA, covering all "information shared with or provided to the Federal Government" under the new measure.
Another provision in the legislation would require that "cyber threat indicators and defensive measures" which companies or individuals share with the federal government be "withheld, without discretion, from the public." The Senate bill, which is expected to come to the floor soon, also seeks to shut off any access to that information under state or local freedom of information laws.
There are extremely troubling parts of the bill relating to whistleblowers and journalistic sources as well. Dozens of organizations protested a variety of draconian provisions last year in a letter to Congress, and while some whistleblower protections have been added, as Open the Government described a couple months ago, the bill still has huge problems:
[T]he bill still allows cybersecurity information to be used to investigate and prosecute whistleblowers or journalists under the Espionage Act. As the Sunshine in Government Initiative noted last summer, CISA’s broad definitions “would grant the federal government the authority to engage in the warrantless collection of journalists’ communications records…if the government deems the journalists, or the confidential sources they work with, ‘security vulnerabilities’ or ‘cybersecurity threats’ potentially ‘adversely impacting’ the confidentiality of information stored on government computers."
As Stanford’s Director of Civil Liberties Jennifer Granick wrote at Just Security last week, there are narrow ways of sharing information that can improve cybersecurity that don’t involve handing over everyone’s personal information. These bills, on the other hand, will only open the door to more mass surveillance. To protect the security of journalists, sources, and all Americans, we need stronger privacy laws, not more loopholes.
Dangerous 'cybersecurity' bills going through Congress threaten the rights of journalists and whistleblowers [freedom.press]
Apple has joined Facebook, Spotify and YouTube in tossing Alex Jones and InfoWars material from their platforms. Apple has removed the entire library for five of Infowars’ six podcasts from its iTunes and Podcast apps, BuzzFeed News has learned. Among the podcasts, which were removed from Apples’ iTunes directory, are the show “War Room” as […]
A 3 percent climb in share price made Apple the world’s first trillion-dollar publicly-traded company. Apple’s ascent from the brink of bankruptcy to the world’s most valuable public company has been a business tour de force, marked by rapid innovation, a series of smash-hit products and the creation of a sophisticated, globe-spanning supply chain that […]
Twitter’s stock closed 20.5% on Friday after the company announced it lost 1 million active users. More user loss is predicted.
From self-driving cars to Siri, we’ve already gotten a taste of what AI can do, and now this groundbreaking technology is making its way to education and revolutionizing the way we learn new languages. Mondly uses state-of-the-art speech recognition to help you speak foreign languages like a true local. Lifetime subscriptions are on sale for […]
We’ve all used Excel at some point in our careers, but chances are most of us have only scratched the surface of what this ubiquitous program can do. From automating simple tasks to presenting data through beautiful charts and PivotTables, Excel brings a ton of utility to the table that can make a huge impact […]
Traveling isn’t always the most comfortable experience, but at least you have your music to keep you company on those long flights. That is, until your chatty neighbor and that crying baby three seats over drown out your playlist. These Paww WaveSound 3 Noise-Cancelling Bluetooth Headphones block up to 20 decibels of audio, so you can […]