The Authors Guild has been trying to get a court to shut down Google's book-scanning/book-search program for more than a decade.
Last October, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals -- the most publisher-friendly court in America -- ruled that the program was legal. Today, the Supreme Court settled the question forever, by declining to hear the Authors Guild's appeal.
I've written a lot about this, but here's the tl;dr: if making a copy in order to create a search index violates copyright, then all search engines are illegal, because they contain billions, if not trillions, of copyrighted works that they ingest in order to create search indexes.
The Supreme Court did not comment in its order other than to say that Justice Elena Kagan did not participate.
Google, for its part, urged the justices to side against the writers because, in the end, their works would be more readily discovered. "Google Books gives readers a dramatically new way to find books of interest," Google's brief said. (PDF) "By formulating their own text queries and reviewing search results, users can identify, determine the relevance of, and locate books they might otherwise never have found."
Unlike other forms of Google search, Google does not display advertising to book searchers, nor does it receive payment if a searcher uses Google's link to buy a copy. Google's book scanning project started in 2004. Working with major libraries like Stanford, Columbia, the University of California, and the New York Public Library, Google has scanned and made machine-readable more than 20 million books. Many of them are nonfiction and out of print.
Fair use prevails as Supreme Court rejects Google Books copyright case
[David Kravets/Ars Technica]
ORDERS IN PENDING CASES [Supreme Court]
(Image: Librarians Against DRM, Listen to My Voice, CC-BY-SA)
To my delight and awe, I have discovered a whole, new-to-me universe of "realistic flame" effect LED lightbulbs, which produce the illusion that you have a goblet of raging flame sticking out of your lightsocket: the bulbs come in a wide variety of shapes and sizes (and can also be had in fanciful colors, for […]
Leafcutter Designs of Oakland, California now has adorable mini metal mailboxes ($18 each) made to stuff full of their tiny letters and packages. Wee key included. You may already know that Leafcutter’s founder Lea Redmond is behind the popular World’s Smallest Post Service. This mailbox “bank” is perfect for sending tiny mail within your household, […]
Comcast offered to get internet service to (96% of) the good people of Charlemont, Mass in exchange for a $462,123 subsidy; instead, the town of 1300 voted to reject the offer and spend $1.4M to build their own super-fast fiber network.
Adobe’s design software catalog is essential to any graphics program, as much for their simplicity as their versatility. Anyone can be an effective graphic designer with tools like Illustrator and InDesign – and the right training in their potential. That’s where the Adobe CC A-Z Lifetime Bundle comes in. Whether you’re getting your feet wet […]
Businesses of any size continue to use PDFs despite – and perhaps because of – their stubborn resistance to simple editing. But for those who need a little flexibility on their documentation, the search is over for alternative software. PDF Expert for Mac is the catch-all solution for wrangling those PDFs, and it’s available at […]
When it comes to tech, smaller is better, and these items fit the bill both in terms of size and price. We’ve rounded up our favorite stocking-ready gadgets, most of which are already on sale – and you can take an additional 15% off any of them with the special code MERRY15. iPM 3-in-1 Fast […]