This wonderful little video by Randy Olson lays out one argument for why as a public political speaker, Donald Trump is perceived to be such a crowd-pleaser, and Hillary Clinton gets weaker scores. It's all about narrative design.
Mr. Olson is the author of the wonderful science communication book “Houston, We Have a Narrative: Why Science Needs Story.”
About this video analyzing Trump and Clinton's styles, Olson writes:
Over the past year pundits have evaluated the speeches and debate performances of the Presidential candidates according to a variety of criteria including length of words, length of sentences, grade level of language and all sorts of other things.
But here’s a different way to look at what they say using The Narrative Index.
It’s a simple number that's just the ratio of the words But to And. “And" is a the most common word of agreement used in setting up narrative points. “But" is the most common word of contradiction, used for establishing a narrative thread.
When you start to calculate these ratios — simply the BUTS divided by the ANDS, multiplied by 100 to make it a whole number -- a world of patterns emerges.
"South Park" creators Matt Stone and Trey Parker. REUTERS
On an archival Reddit post, Olson explained where this line of inquiry comes from -- the Matt Stone and Trey Parker Comedy Central animated series "South Park."
I found it in a narrative template I crafted and labeled as “The ABT.” It comes indirectly from the co-creators of the Emmy and Peabody award-winning animated series, South Park. In a 2011 Comedy Central documentary about the show, they talked about their “Rule of Replacing” which they use for editing scripts. They replace the word “and” with “but” or “therefore” to improve storytelling — so I turned it into the “And, But, Therefore” template (the ABT). It is now the central tool in my mission to keep people from being boring. I present it in my new book, “Houston, We Have A Narrative,” use it in my work with individual scientists, and have built my Story Circles Narrative Training program around it, which I now run with scientists from NIH and USDA. Together, with this marvelous narrative tool, we are fighting to make the world a tiny bit less boring of a place.
The BUT Candidate Vs the AND Candidate
Edited by John Rael. Music by Andru Aesthetik.
(Thanks, Mike Backes!)
As long as he’s only up against one candidate and they don’t do anything stupid, Trump would lose to a sausage in 2020. Fox News has him deep underwater against every likely Dem candidate. A Fox News poll released Thursday showed President Trump losing head-to-head matchups against four of the top Democratic presidential primary contenders. […]
Wefail offers this charming collection of four banknotes, each featuring one of the four “horsemen of the apocalypse”, at least when it comes to the demise and presumed annihilation of Britain’s political stability. $50 a set. Four Wefail banknotes depicting the four horsemen: May, Rees-Mogg, Bojo and Thatcher. Early in 2019 I was asked to […]
Israel barred Democractic congresswomen Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib from entering the country today, an hour after Trump tweeted that the country would show “great weakness” if it allows them to visit. Israel gave as its rationale the congresswomen’s support of boycotts against the country over its treatment of Palestinians. The BBC: Ilhan Omar and […]
Want to make a hit? The right software is out there for anyone, but any music producer will tell you that finding the right sound can still take time and talent. Still, the right tools are a great shortcut, which makes this Synth & Sound Pack Bundle absolutely priceless. And now that it’s on sale […]
Let’s face it: People at the gym aren’t bragging about their headphones. If they were that great, they’d be listening to them instead of talking about them. So while we’re sure those new PowerBeats Pro earbuds are something special, why would you shell out $250 for a tiny pair of speakers when comparable ones are […]
Big companies take on big projects. When they do that, they need a project manager to lay out a roadmap for the entire team – and they’re typically willing to pay a big paycheck to the person who can fill those shoes. So what does it take to become a project manager? If you don’t […]