Strong Female Protagonist, Book Two: the hard philosophical questions of superheroism and compassion
It's been nearly four years since the first crowdfunded collection of Brennan Lee Mulligan and Molly Ostertag's webcomic Strong Female Protagonist was published; the second volume, published this week, traces not just the evolution of its protagonist, the superhero Alison "Mega Girl" Green, but of its creators, who have found new and amazing depths to plumb and heights to soar to.
In book two, Alison Green has "taken off her mask" and retired from superheroing, getting out of the trade ahead of her peers, who are abandoning the calling en masse, disenchanted with fighting petty criminals and facing hard questions about the accountability and legitimacy of superheroes coercing compliance from the baseline humans around them.
But not all of the superheroes have given it up. One of Mega Girls old super-partners is using her invisibility power to execute rapists who escape justice and is working her way up through the judges who let them off and the other enablers.
Alison has a new philosophy teacher, a kind of larger-than-life figure who forces her to confront the hard questions she's been dodging, look at them head-on in the presence of her peers, who view her with a mix of respect and fear.
Alison's life out of class is also philosophically provocative: between rescuing people from burning buildings with the local fire department, going viral after foiling a date-rape and a party and then berating the other party goers for failing to take action, and contending with other supers who blame her for the mysterious invisible slasher who is cutting the throats of acquitted rapists, Alison has a lot to be introspective about and precious little time to do so.
Instead of a lot of philosophical maundering, Mulligan and Ostertag deliver tons of great superhero action, a cross between Mystery Men and X-Men -- and then, as each adventure builds, as each super is introduced, they use the action to deliver another philosophical puzzler, wound around the ancient Greeks, the selfishness of Rand, the contemporary discourse around social justice and safe spaces, giving each a fair shake, showing the downsides of each, and the upsides, and challenging the reader (and Alison) to chart a course through intellectual problems that are every bit as hard-fought as the super-battles Alison is fighting.
It is a wonderful combination, a return to the philosophical roots of superhero stories (remember, Superman's creators started with Nietzsche), with subtlety, wit, action and humor.
I can't wait for the next volume -- I hope it isn't another four years in coming.
Strong Female Protagonist Book Two [Brennan Lee Mulligan and Molly Ostertag]
Have you ever wanted to find a book, but you don’t know the title? This video and article from Make Use Of has some ideas that could help. Suggestions include using Google Book Search, BookFinder, WorldCat, The Library of Congress, and Ask a Librarian. Image: Jumpstory/CC0
If you’re in the market for book recommendations to fill up your stay-at-home hours, here’s a short list of favorites from Bill Gates. Check out his longer list on his blog, GatesNotes blog.
I’m honored that in the latest issue of The Burning Shore, Erik Davis, scholar of West Coast counterculture, reviewed The Family Acid: California, Roger Steffens’s far-out photo album I published with my Ozma Records partner Tim Daly! Erik’s excellent essay is a double review, also focusing on the Anthology Editions reprint of Dennis Stock’s striking […]
Virus quarantines and shuttered restaurants sent millions of Americans back to their homes, only to rediscover the joys of firing up an oven and cooking something special for themselves. Whether by desire, necessity, or both, many of us have certainly been spending more time in the kitchen these last few months. And we haven’t just […]
Now that the world is starting to re-emerge from its self-imposed COVID-19 quarantine, we’re all going to have to start making some adjustments to both short-term and long-term changes. And the questions… Should customers be hounded out of a store if they aren’t wearing a face mask? Are crocheted face masks safe or not? And […]
Maybe you had a piano teacher as a kid that drove you off the instrument forever. Or maybe you always wished for some serious training, but never found the time. Whether you have dreams of tossing off a Beethoven or Chopin piece at the drop of a hat or you have visions of being the […]