In late 2017, we learned that patent trolls (especially pharma patent gougers) were paying US Native Indian tribes to act as fronts for them in order to block review and cancellation of bogus patents -- the tribes have a treaty right to "sovereign immunity," which protects them from some forms of litigation.
The moved sparked Congressional investigations and dire warnings from pharma execs that the trick was so dirty it would hasten the day that the public decided enough was enough and demanded universal healthcare.
Now, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has unanimously held that sovereign immunity does not protect patent trolls, because reviewing a patent isn't a lawsuit, it's an "agency enforcement action," and that's not covered by sovereign immunity arrangements.
In short, an IPR isn’t a lawsuit. With no lawsuit, there can be no sovereign immunity.
As the three-judge panel concluded: "The Director’s important role as a gatekeeper and the Board’s authority to proceed in the absence of the parties convinces us that the USPTO is acting as the United States in its role as a superior sovereign to reconsider a prior administrative grant and protect the public interest in keeping patent monopolies ‘within their legitimate scope.’"
Allergan can now choose to appeal further to the Supreme Court of the United States, which only agrees to hear a tiny percentage of cases.
Court: Native American tribe can’t be a “sovereign” shield during patent review [Cyrus Farivar/Ars Technica]
They told the public everything would be okay with the virus outbreak. Then they privately dumped stocks. Over the past 24 hours, news has spread that various U.S. lawmakers received advance private briefings about the severity of an oncoming coronavirus/COVID-19 pandemic — then, they sold stocks before the public knew how bad it would get, […]
President Trump today announced that he is commuting the prison sentence of Rod Blagojevich, a former Illinois governer jailed for corruption, and pardoning Bernard Kerik, the former New York Police Commissioner jailed for tax fraud. Blagojevich attempted to sell Barack Obama’s senate seat; Kerik was found to have accepted a $250,000 bribe from a billionaire […]
“What does this guy worth $60 billion own, who wants to be president?”
Python is everywhere. Just look under the hood of virtually every major tech player of the 21st century and you’re likely to find a whole lot of Python-based coding language staring back at you. Case in point: Netflix. You may not know it, but from its security protocols to its much-hyped recommendations, it turns out […]
There are definite benefits to the whole work from home thing. The commute is a breeze. The dress code is supremely casual. And your boss has to work a lot harder to actually find you. Despite the joys, there are still some clear downsides to the whole home office thing as well. Job focus can […]
If you’re routinely prone to being stressed out, hurried or generally made out-of-sorts by the hectic pace of the world and life changes, then…yikes. We don’t envy what you must be going through these days. Right about now, even the most zen and centered among us are bound to be feeling some level of anxiety […]