In 2016, EFF sued
the US Government on behalf of Andrew "bunnie" Huang
and Matthew Green, both of whom wanted to engage in normal technological
activities (auditing digital security, editing videos, etc)
that put at risk from Section 1201 of the Digital Millennium
EFF's lawsuit argues that Green and Huang's activities are
constitutionally protected, and that DMCA 1201 -- which imposes a
blanket ban on bypassing Digital Rights Management (DRM), without adequate safeguards for speech -- was unconstitutional.
The case has been sitting in limbo for over two years, waiting for the
judge to rule on whether our clients’ claims could proceed, and, at
long last, the judge
has ruled and the case will go forward!
As my EFF colleague Kit Walsh writes,
the ruling is a "mixed bag":
The ruling is a mixed bag. While the "as-applied" First Amendment claims
will go forward, the court did not agree that rulemaking by the
Librarian of Congress is subject to judicial review under the
Administrative Procedure Act, even when the Librarian is performing an
executive branch function rather than a congressional one. The court
also did not agree that the Librarian's rulemaking is subject to the
First Amendment scrutiny that applies when a government official is
making determinations about what speech to permit. Finally, the court
saw no need to adjudicate the claims that Section 1201 is overly broad,
because it concluded that determining the constitutionality of the
statute as applied to the plaintiffs will turn on the same issues as
with other potential targets of the law.
The bottom line is that the case is going forward and we will continue
the fight to help you understand and modify the devices in your life and
remix the culture we all share.
First Amendment Case Against Restrictive Copyright Law Can Proceed, Says
[Kit Walsh/EFF Deeplinks]
My latest Locus Magazine column is DRM Broke Its Promise, which recalls the days when digital rights management was pitched to us as a way to enable exciting new markets where we'd all save big by only buying the rights we needed (like the low-cost right to read a book for an hour-long plane ride), […]
For decades, architectural critic and photographer John Margolies obsessively documented roadside attractions: vernacular architecture, weird sculpture, odd businesses and amusements. By his death in 2016, his collection consisted of more than 11,000 slides (he published books of his favorites, with annotations).
After the EU Copyright Directive passed with a slim majority that only carried because some MEPs got confused and pressed the wrong button, the government of Poland filed a legal challenge with the European Court of Justice, arguing that the Directive -- and its rule requiring that all online discourse be filtered by black-box algorithms […]
When it comes to data analytics or deep learning, there’s one language behind the apps and algorithms that power the biggest companies of today: Python. The best part about this tool is that as versatile as it is, it’s actually fairly easy to learn. But mastery? For that, you need more than just a beginners’ […]
Your smartphone’s GPS is a modern necessity for some trips, but how do you use it safely? It’s been a problem ever since phones went mobile. A certain phone mount even shelled out the money for a commercial during the Big Game, so clearly there’s a market for the solution. Turns out there are a […]
There’s reading for pleasure, and then there’s reading for fuel; absorbing the great ideas in nonfiction books so you can apply them in your own life. In today’s hectic pace, it can be difficult to find the time to do that reading – especially for the entrepreneurs and professionals who can benefit the most from […]