From the Electronic Frontier Foundation comes the heartening news that yet another "copyright troll" has given up on the shakedown tactic of using cheap John Doe lawsuits to compel ISPs to surrender details of their customers so that lawyers can threaten to sue them unless they turn over a few hundred bucks to make the whole thing go away.
Late last week, Mick Haig Productions dismissed its case against 670 "John Does," claiming they had infringed the company's copyrighted materials on a file-sharing service. The notice of dismissal came after EFF and Public Citizen argued that Mick Haig should not be allowed to send subpoenas for the Does' identifying information, because it had sued hundreds of people in one case, in the wrong jurisdiction and without meeting the constitutional standard for obtaining identifying information.
"Copyright owners have a right to protect their works, but they can't use shoddy and unfair tactics to do so," said EFF Intellectual Property Director Corynne McSherry. "When adult film companies launch these cases, there is the added pressure of embarrassment associated with pornography, which can convince those ensnared in the suits to quickly pay what's demanded of them, whether or not they have legitimate defenses. That's why it's so important to make sure the process is fair."
Mick Haig Productions dropped the case just 48 hours after EFF and PC demanded that it withdraw subpoenas Mick Haig's lawyer apparently issued while the question of whether the court should allow the subpoenas at all was still under consideration by the court.
Copyright Troll Gives Up in Porn-Downloading Case
report this ad
Six weeks after Mother Jones published its explosive undercover expose on the abuses, shortcomings and waste in America’s vast private prison system, the Department of Justice has issued a ban on renewal of federal private prison contracts (where they are not able to do this, officials are told to “substantially reduce” the scope of those […]
Starting in 2000, Walmart began an aggressive cost-cutting campaign that removed greeters, reduced floor staff, and replaced cashiers with automated checkouts; the more this went on, the higher the crime-rate at Walmart soared, everything from shoplifting to deadly violence. In true Walmart style, the world’s largest retailer has offloaded the costs associated with this crime […]
Francis Tseng’s simulator game invites you to “grow your startup and please those investors until there’s nothing left to give” by building biotech, defense, machine learning, cloud computing, drone and space companies with a crew of employees whose low wages can be mitigated with bulletproof coffee and whose products can be sold with “causewashing” sponsorships […]
When carrying around a bulky DSLR camera isn’t ideal, we use these impressive add-ons to help turn our smartphones into quality cameras. Flexible Tripod for Smartphones and CamerasThe Flexible Tripod for Smartphones and Cameras ($8.99) is perfect for capturing a group shot or leveling out your phone on an uneven surface. Its flexible legs can wrap around anything, even a tree branch, […]
With all of the digital information out there—from credit card numbers to Instagram posts to consumer behavior—there’s so much data that businesses struggle with the task of storing, managing, and analyzing the information. That’s why Big Data is one of the fastest growing career paths in the world. Big Data is a giant, intimidating subject, which is why […]
We’re always searching for, borrowing, and losing Lightning cables, and that’s why we are loading up with the Apple MFi-Certified Lightning Cable: 3-Pack.These Apple-certified USB cables let you charge your iPhone, iPad, or iPod via any USB port—whether you prefer your computer or the Apple USB Power Adapter. And since there’s three of them, you never […]
report this ad
The first paragraph quoted is some level-5 grammar yoga, seemingly designed to avoid using the word “quash.”
Thanks, EFF! Down with bottom-dwelling, shameless and unethical firms like Mick Haig!
Whoa! Not so fast. Too soon to call victory. Several people I know have been recently hit by threat letters from the ESA (Entertainment Software Association) doing exactly the same thing as this.
It seems like, if one company is giving up, another one is taking over.
I’ve mentioned this before. I worked at a law firm who was contracted to “troll”. They sent letters to any business they wanted demanding physical proof of Windows Licenses. If they could not produce proof or proof that the legitimate license they did have was purchased from a licensed dealer then they had to pay a “fine” and also purchase new licensed software. This law firms only premise was if the company could not produce a license then the product was counterfeit. I quit. You can blame the new troll tactics; they are modeled after The Business Software Alliance (“BSAâ€) and Software & Information Industry Association (“SIIAâ€)practices who can, at any time, demand to perform an audit of your system. Read the attached Software Audit Blog.
http://www.scottandscottllp.com/main/blogindex.aspx?id=154
IANAL, but my impression is that they are simply dropping the suits before a ruling is made not because they are admitting defeat but as a way of preventing the court from creating a precedent. I would not be surprised if they simply resumed this practice after some time has passed.