NZ bans award-winning YA novel after complaints from conservative Christian group

Ted Dawe's Into the River won the 2013 New Zealand Post Children's Book prize; businesses that sell, lend or gift it face fines of up to NZD10,000.

The book is aimed at teen boys -- a relative rarity in YA literature -- and features sex scenes, a slang term for genitals, and drug use. The group Family First got the NZ Film and Literature Board of Review to ban the book. It is being pulled from stores, libraries, and schools across the country.

The ban is interim and will be finalised or lifted based on a later hearing.

“I have taught in secondary schools for the past forty years. Much of this time has been spent encouraging boys to read. Part of the challenge was to find books that ‘spoke’ to them. This meant books about issues that were relevant to them and written in a style that was authentic,” he said.

“There are many issues that young adults can not take to other people. They want to do their own thinking about them. There is no better, no more private medium for this than the novel.

“In this relatively safe context the teenager can navigate through issues such as race, sexual orientation, body issues, class discrimination and bullying and harassment. They can test their responses against the main characters and calibrate the differences without the need to discuss.”

“The last banned book was entitled How to Build a Bazooka. Perhaps the content of Into the River is a bazooka fired into the complacent middle class oligarchy that rules this country.”

New Zealand bans award-winning teenage novel after outcry from Christian group [Eleanor Ainge Roy/The Guardian]

Notable Replies

  1. Kimmo says:

    GDIAF, fucking wowsers. I hope there's a digital version of this already...

  2. doop says:

    The ban is an interim measure until a more permanent decision is made, at which point I expect the ban will be lifted and the Streisand effect will kick in.

  3. No self-respecting liberal democracy needs a "Film and Literature Board of Review", a "Classification Office", or a "Chief Censor".

    My favorite right-wing goon had a pretty amusing response:

  4. Interim measure shouldn't be banning. The default should be "hands off". Otherwise all books could be banned until they can be investigated and found acceptable to the saps that banned them in the first place

  5. I just spent an unseemly long time unsuccessfully looking up New Zealand slang terms for genitalia.

Continue the discussion

8 more replies