Is this Louie/Charlie Brown parody hilariously depressing or just depressing? Or hilarious?

(Video link) Robot Chicken has done its fair share of childhood-ruining. Now ADHD -- Animation Domination High Def -- has lampooned the sacred holiday chestnut, A Charlie Brown Christmas, and imagined the Peanuts Gang as grownups. Boring, dissatisfied grownups with several health issues, which just so happens to be one driving force of the FX sitcom Louie! I can't say this mashup is as whimsical as Cthulhu Snoopy, but it does have Homeless Pigpen, who I'm sure has many whimsical thoughts in his head. (via Laughing Squid)

Discuss

23 Responses to “Is this Louie/Charlie Brown parody hilariously depressing or just depressing? Or hilarious?”

  1. Jorpho says:

    It’s going to be hard to top the Robot Chicken “It’s the Great Pumpkin” parody.  (It still seems to be on Youtube.)

    And speaking of parodies, the way, waaay over the top Weapon Brown webcomic recently finished its four-year run, concluding with its epic post-apocalyptic showdown between Weapon Brown and CALv1n.

  2. vrplumber says:

    Family Guy did it ;)

  3. signsofrain says:

    Okay, full series of Robot Chicken is gonna hit my torrent queue because of this. Thank you. I’ll probably buy the show too, in a few months once the Christmas budget hit is past.

  4. Deidzoeb says:

    Q: In the Peanuts newspaper strip, which character said he wanted to stand out in the rain until he caught pneumonia and died?
    A: Trick question. At least three of them did. Charlie Brown, Linus and Snoopy at different times over the years. (Maybe others. I haven’t read them all.)

    Which is to say, the kids were already depressed and depressing. That’s one reason why it resonated so deeply with kids and adults over the years. … Until the 80s, and Schulz blew it with all the crap about Snoopy’s siblings. Ugh.

  5. I like the credits. (and all of it)

  6. Henry Pootel says:

    Are you kidding?  With that ending?  I call that hilarious victory!

  7. I really wanted so much more from this, but it felt high-schooly and perfunctory. :( 

    Didn’t do a thing to capture the awkward tenderness that makes Charlie Brown and Louie both so damned funny and profound. They had a great concept and ruined it for me with the gay jokes and stock pessimism — not because those things are inherently awful to joke about, but because they’re so obvious and boring in this context. (By contrast, I love Louie’s poker-game conversations about homosexuality. Those actually strike me as provocative and sincere.)

    Being crass isn’t enough on its own, you know? I think they could’ve made a much better short by keeping the grown-up kids at more subtle and plausible levels of fucked-up. Serial-killer Linus isn’t nearly as interesting as the neurotic kid we had in the first place. :)

    • Kimmo says:

      Now you mention it… yeah.

      Hopefully someone will be inspired by your comment to do a more fitting Charlie/Louie mashup.

    • Dean Putney says:

      Thanks for nailing this. I felt like this was a promising Louie/Peanuts intro followed by lazy “Charlie Brown grew up and everything is awful” jokes, completed with a Louie-esque credits sequence. There’s a pretty decent amount of unrealized potential here.

    • Girard says:

      Yeah I mean, I know it’s a dicey game trying to take on two of the most uncontested genius exemplars of their respective forms, but this video fell far, far short of the mark. Total tonal misfire that missed any of the melancholia present in either Peanuts or Louie, and went in for sophomoric, Seth McFarlane-style “‘dark’ ‘edgy’ subversion of cherished childhood property” tropes (which, of course, uses a middle-school notion of what is ‘dark’ or ‘edgy’…).

  8. CaptainPedge says:

    LOL MARCIE AND PATTY ARE LESBEEEEEUNZ! SO ORIGINAL!

  9. Antinous / Moderator says:

    Every Charlie Brown special is horribly depressing.  Weren’t they supposed to be?

  10. TheOven says:

    This is pretty much what I thought of the original Charlie Brown and gang; depressed fuck-ups. Why or how they ever got animated is beyond me. 

    • Antinous / Moderator says:

      I assumed that it was driven by parents who could show it to their children and say, “Look at the crap that we had for entertainment, so shut up and be grateful for Scooby-Doo.”

      • Girard says:

        The fact that they were so bleak is part of the reason why the Peanuts stuff is emphatically not crap. Kids’ media (or popular media in general) with an honest, relatable emotional core is so rare, and the loud, stupid and obnoxious (e.g. Scooby Doo) is so prevalent – there’s  reason why Schulz is lauded as the master of the comic strip, and why the TV specials remain perennial favorites.

  11. CognitiveDissident says:

    Where’s Sally?
    (I hope that she wasn’t one of “bodies” that Linus mentioned.)
    Also, Linus could be on “Hoarders” if he survives the holidays.

  12. Karen Sylte-Munson says:

    Wow.  A lot of people don’t understand the genius of “Peanuts” at all.  That’s really interesting!  I mean, I had no idea this particular comic strip/animated cartoon flew so far over some people’s heads.  I’m not going to even attempt to write about why “Peanuts,” in its heyday, was right up there with the best of the best comics/cartoons ever done.  But I will say that if you think that all the characters were just “depressed fuck-ups” then you are missing the larger point that, in fact, ALL people are exactly that.  And yet, we continue to try to find meaning and to try to forge relationships with one-another.  And sometimes we succeed.

    This parody didn’t work for me, BTW.  Too reliant on overused stereotypes throughout. 

Leave a Reply