Here's a brain-meltingly cool proof of the bizarre mathematical truth that the sum of all positive integers (1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5....) is -1/12. This is not only provably true, it's also foundational to certain testable elements of physics. In other words: not just a logical curiosity, but also the bedrock of real-world, useful stuff.

ASTOUNDING: 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + ... = -1/12
(*via Kottke*)

report this ad

My UK publisher, Head of Zeus, has published the official tour schedule for the British tour for Walkaway, with stops in Oxford (with Tim Harford), London (with Laurie Penny), Liverpool (with Chris Pak), Birmingham, and the Hay Literary Festival (with Dr Adam Rutherford). Hope to see you there!

My publicist just found an extra box of the cool promotional Walkaway multitools, and she’s generously offered to give them to the next 100 people to reserve tickets to the May 7th Walkaway event at Chicago’s Royal George Theater, where I’m presenting with CARDS AGAINST HUMANITY creator Max Temkin (current ticket-holders, don’t worry, you get […]

Carol from Cheapass Games writes, “In our continuing quest to bring back the very best classic Cheapass Games, we’re creating a new boxed set of Button Men, our strategy dice combat game. This time around, the characters will appear on cards, rather than pin-back buttons, but since they’re all 1950s era gangsters, the ‘button men’ […]

All moms are different. But all moms like getting flowers on Mother’s Day, and that’s a fact (not, however a fact we can document in any fashion.) Instead of getting chewed out for forgetting to call her on the second Sunday of May, you can take care of it ahead of time with Teleflora’s flower […]

Yeah, Bluetooth audio is pretty common these days, so why should you care about these earbuds? Look how happy that woman up above looks. She’s got FRESHeBUDS in. Boom. There’s your reason. She’s also at the beach and it appears to be a very nice day.But for the sake of promotion, wireless earbuds are fast becoming the […]

“Gets stuff done,” is a good way to be described by anybody. Especially by coworkers or bosses. Because whether you’re in finance or a children’s librarian, stuff needs to get done. But how do you make sure stuff gets done? You definitely can’t do all the stuff yourself, unless your company/organization/government office consists entirely of you. And […]

report this ad

To quote Talking Barbie: "Math is hard! Let's go shopping!"

No, this is not a proof. Sorry. By violating the rules you can "prove" all kinds of stuff, like that 1 is equal to zero (usually by hiding the fact that you divided by zero), and with many divergent series you can produce any sum you want by fooling around with the order of the terms.

I was going to complain how adults prefer to get information like this written down, rather than in a video format, but seeing as it's all apparently bullshit anyway... thanks for sparing me that?

As soon as they said the sum of an undefined series was not undefined, I stopped watching.

But I shouldn't be at all surprised if they end up deriving a counterintuitive result from a bad premise.

Since I'm a mathematician I feel obligated to say two things:

1) The sum of all positive integers isn't -1/12. That sum does not converge.

2) There is a way of making sense of this

formalsumwhich gives it the value of -1/12. That value isn't unique and calling this value the "sum of the positive integers" is at best weasel wording.Here is a better explanation: In calculus, you learn that the harmonic series:

\sum_{n=1}^{\infty} 1/n

diverges. Let's change this a bit to get a function R(s):

R(s) = \sum_{n=1}^{\infty} 1/(n^s)

This is the famous "Riemann zeta function" and the harmonic series is R(1).

Now what about R(-1)? Well, if you just look at the definition you would see that

R(-1)

= \sum_{n=1}^{\infty} 1/(n^-1)

= \sum_{n=1}^{\infty} n

i.e. the sum of all positive integers. The thing is, if you tried to graph this definition of R(s) around s=-1, you wouldn't get anything at all. However, if you started in a place where the definition did make sense (s>1) and tried to extrapolate the values the values from those (analytic continuation), then you would see a continuous function with value

-1/12at s=-1.This depends on identifying the sum of all positive integers with a value of the Riemann zeta function. You could easily pick something else and get a different value.