If Meat Loaf had a son who did Rebecca Black covers...

Discuss

38 Responses to “If Meat Loaf had a son who did Rebecca Black covers...”

  1. Anonymous says:

    Wow. This is just terrible.

  2. Nate the great says:

    Is it just me or is there something wrong with an industry when the songs that mock major releases are actually better than the original?

  3. tom frog says:

    I’m waiting for the Mark Knopfler/Eric Clapton version, myself…

  4. dculberson says:

    This is actually amazing. I similarly had not heard the original and made the mistake of looking it up before watching this video. He manages to re-imagine everything about it and turn it into a masterpiece. I love Mulholland.

  5. Antinous / Moderator says:

    Is it just me or is there something wrong with an industry when the songs that mock major releases are actually better than the original?

    I don’t understand why they didn’t replace Justin Timberlake when this came out.

  6. davy_k says:

    This makes me wish Matt Mullholland was my best friend. In a way, he already is.

  7. Disasteradio says:

    Why are people everywhere attributing this to “The Record Industry”? It’s not like she’s even *signed*, unless you count ARK which is, like it or not, an independant label. Haha.. or, for some, are the chickens of participatory / Youtube culture that have come home to roost too hideous to acknowledge? ..

    Anyway if we’re talking “Trust Fund Pop”, “My Jeans” by Jenna Rose is an INFINITELY stronger track, haha man am I loving this stuff: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7DwT_2QQU64 (Trig bought a new Blackberry)

  8. Blue says:

    I always assumed the Rebecca Black song was just vanity publishing – a company that produces videos & the buyer’s music with pretty good production values in return for cash – and nothing more.

    Anything else just doesn’t make sense!

  9. Anonymous says:

    The second I hit play my autistic son shot out of his chair, rushed across the room, leaned down over my computer for a look/listen, then yelled in my face… “Turn it up!” (c: His taste is pretty selective. James Taylor and The Beatles, I guess I should throw some Meatloaf in the mix.

  10. Anonymous says:

    Interview w/the girl: http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/video/rebecca-black-dont-think-im-worst-singer-13164800

    She’s got kind of a good attitude about the whole thing.

  11. drunken_orangetree says:

    When I first saw Rebecca Black’s video I thought it was a typically cute, cookie-cutter pop song. That people are latching on to this song as something extraordinary surely says more about those people than Rebecca Black. And why would someone direct that kind of venom–”execrable ‘Friday’”–at a 13 year old girl?

  12. Godfree says:

    Okay, you know what? I don’t even care. And I’m one of those who don’t like comments from people who don’t care. I don’t like Meat Loaf necessarily, I don’t know from Rebecca Black. I don’t know why She Must Not Be Named. After reading these comments, I’m certainly not going to bother watching the video.

    As far as I’m concerned, She Who Must Not Be Named rhymes, like bardfinn suggested, with Farrah Failin.

    So as not to be a complete waste of bandwidth, here: read some Pharyngula.
    http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2011/03/so_thats_what_they_mean_by_the.php

  13. Andrea James says:

    @drunken_orangetree (and perennially grumpy lmnop): The song IS execrable (and not written by her). In fact, the song and video content were largely out of her control. However, it’s the perfect storm of execrable elements that makes it very hard to get out of your head. I made no negative comments about Rebecca Black, and I believe the cover is actually a pretty clever reply that isn’t mean-spirited.

    People making fun of things… welcome to the internet!

    • lmnop says:

      I think my perennial grumpiness has a lot to do with the boingboing hipster hypocrisy (or maybe it’s just the internet in general). You know, the whole sort of “I liked them before they became famous” vibe, like we’ve all got the inside track here or something. How photoshopping sucks and we call people on it, but if someone else gets their dander up about possible photoshopping, then we’ll call them on it, too (but no one better call us out on anything).

      But hey, it’s the internet, so we make fun of things (such as, in our earlier colloquy, someone who wrote a whimsical NYT op-ed piece). Most often it’s commenters who are the most damaging, but the before-the-cut content often does a good job of nudging the rest of us into action.

      Also, I’m not sure how “she who must not be named” is meant to be taken, if not as a comment on that person… but apparently this is a positive or at the very least neutral comment on her? (presumably, if the comment was directed solely at the song and not the person, it would be the song that must not be named)

  14. brerrabbit23 says:

    I’m still waiting for Johnny Cash’s estate to release his cover of Gir’s “Doom Song”.

  15. Anonymous says:

    I’m so conflicted. The lyrics are completely worthless. Yet the singing and production, while no Meatloaf, is quite good.

    Despite the sage advice of several here, I went and listened to the original. I’m conflicted about that too. I mean, she’s just a kid, but the Zeroth Law demands I protect humanity by “disliking” it.

    Decided it was not important enough to spend emotion on, and went to my playlists for some Mahler to calm my soul.

  16. tw15 says:

    At least In England we don’t have middle class pop stars and talent show contestants dominating our music charts. Come to think of it…

    I don’think anyone in Europe has heard of either of these people.

  17. Suburbancowboy says:

    ARK Music Factory will make a video for anyone who pays them.

    I would guess that ARK takes a listen to the singer, and based off of looks and vocal skills, decides which song from their catalog of crap they churn out, to give them. The worse the singer, the worse the song they give them. Don’t want to waste a potential pop hit on a bad singer. And then they auto tune it to death. That said the girl sounded much better singing live on GMA, than on that awful production.

    If you go to ARk’s page on YouTube, they have an “opening night party” where a bunch of ARK’s “talent” performed. For most of them, it was their first time performing in front of an audience, and they were laughably bad. All of them.

    That isn’t how the music industry works, you aren’t supposed to make a music video, and then play in front of a crowd. You are supposed to bust your ass playing out, and if you are lucky, then you get a music video. And you end up owing the label for it.

  18. jonw says:

    Boingboing, how could you. I read this blog because I try to live in a bubble of things that don’t suck. Please add a warning not to watch/hear the original song. Somewhere a few of my brain cells are now forever wasted, storing the fact that this song exists. Dear god, it is bad.

  19. gijoel says:

    I’m kind of partial to the Bob Dylan cover

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FISHEO3gsM

    Though there’s debate as to whether it’s him or not.

  20. bkad says:

    I had never heard of the original song, so I looked it up. I cannot advise following in my foot steps. If you are similarly ignorant…. stay that way.

  21. SonOfSamSeaborn says:

    We can call this shit a Mulholland chaser, although I don’t think I’ve heard you guys mention SWMNBN before now.

  22. Anonymous says:

    Love the production values…. Touches of Queen – Bohemian Rhapsody.

    The song, especially the original. Gives monkey scrondles.

  23. Anonymous says:

    Listen to bkad! I did not follow his advice and now my ears are bleeding.

  24. Snig says:

    Reminds me of the “If I had a million dollars” cover by BNL. Reversed moods, song much much improved.

  25. mgfarrelly says:

    I confess, I don’t get the outpouring of epic hatred for young Ms. Black’s little song. Shs’s all of 13 years old and the amount of bile being produced over her video seems on par with what your average genocidal dictator would inspire. Take it down a few notches people, really.

    That said, nothing like a fine parodist to make something fun for all.

    • Nate the great says:

      The problem with SWMNBN is that she would best be described as Kei$ha, only without the talent.

      • lmnop says:

        She’s exactly like Ke$ha? Except for the fact her message is completely different and she dresses completely different and she doesn’t really pretend to be a good singer or think people should pay for her music. And except she’s a 13-year-old girl doing what may just be the 21st century equivalent of singing into a hairbrush for the well-heeled set.

        http://www.npr.org/blogs/monkeysee/2011/03/18/134652534/ridiculed-youtube-singer-rebecca-black-grabs-a-mountain-of-bull-by-the-horns

        And the original isn’t a major release, it was a vanity production.

        It was only a few boingboing posts ago that we had outrage over the outrage about the supposedly-photoshopped Wired cover, with the observation that “Angry people will find something to be angry about here!” Well, people are finding something to get angry about over the “Friday” video, and in this case many are taking it out on a 13-year-old girl. A wonderful thing, indeed.

    • Anonymous says:

      The bile could be spewing forth as a direct result of the pure lack of singing talent and turning an old civil rights era song into an abomination that is focused on trivial matters.

      That’s just my guess…

  26. Anonymous says:

    This is GREAT….

    I think I have to cut myself now.

  27. bardfinn says:

    SWMNBN: First name rhymes with “Jelly”, Politicial affiliation GOP;
    alternately First name rhymes with Farrah, Last name rhymes with Failin’, Political affiliation GOP;
    alternately someone who identifies as two distinct long-wavelength visible photonic emission spectra.

  28. Flying_Monkey says:

    Err… Meatloaf is already ‘execrable’. And people who do covers of ‘execrable’ songs in the style of Meatload… I think that makes it triply ‘execrable’: to use Andrea’s metaphour, it’s like using turd-polish on a turd with a turd cloth.

    • dculberson says:

      Meatloaf is “execrable?” Man, you need to get out more! He’s amazing.

      Not everything is Toccata and Fugue in D Minor.

      • Anonymous says:

        Well I for one like Meatloaf and Bach (though I’d choose Bach if I had to give up one forever), don’t care who photoshops what, and recommend listening to this:

        http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Q6gOm39V-s

        Personally, I think my fellow netizens on average would benefit from taking little things just a bit less seriously; but since this is the interwebs, I try not to take the ostensibly serious phrasing of others too seriously.

        In person one can read body language, demeanor, tone of voice, ect… Observing these things, especially over any length of time and multiple encounters, is, IMHO, a much more reliable way to assess the thoughts behind words than what can be plumbed from reading comments like this. Even a writer and/or blogger whose thoughts a reader may have a prolonged and detailed experience with is still, to a significant degree, filtered by the low bandwidth (relative to real-life) of our still nascent cyberspace. Perhaps future generations will find it hard to imagine a net where users couldn’t simply trade thoughts directly. PsiBook anyone? :P

        Aaron

  29. Anonymous says:

    cover is better, by a lot. original singer, rebecca black, needs voice lessons to get the midwest out of her voice, it’s really harsh. It’s not terrible or any worse than a lot of stuff out there. This version is significantly better though.

  30. Anonymous says:

    Wonderful voice but seriously….

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVXrLxOTJk4

    Comparisons to the king of the power ballad only make us old folks go wandering down memory lane.

Leave a Reply