The nature vs. nurture question looms in Orphan Black [s2e5]
Caroline Siede on the latest episode of the BBC's clone drama
Why do people do bad things? The answer is, of course, because they don’t see their actions as villainous. In their minds, the end justifies the means. The weak link of Orphan Black so far has been the rote “bad guys” who populate its world. While the show explored the rich inner lives and goals of Sarah, Cosima, Alison, and Felix, the antagonistic forces felt a bit more like archetypes without clear motivations: the kindly cult leader, the icy business woman, the mysterious scientist. Tonight’s episode course corrects in a big way by lifting the veil on the show’s previously opaque villains. And once you understand someone, it’s a whole lot harder to hate them.
The idea of perspective is emphasized again and again tonight, as we are invited to walk a mile in the shoes (or stilettos in the case of Rachel) of people who do bad things. Gracie didn’t try to suffocate Helena because of an innate propensity for violence. Instead, she was raised with such a cultish devotion to God that she saw artificially created Helena as an abomination. “I didn’t think of it as taking a real life,” she explains. That’s not a shoddy defense; it’s an insight into Gracie’s warped perspective on the world.
The Proletheans are all about loyalty. When their daughter steps over the line they punish her by sewing her lips together, locking her in solitary confinement for 12 hours, and threatening her with a forced pregnancy if she doesn’t comply. Assuming Mark was raised in that environment as well, it’s more understandable (although not justifiable) that he continually does as Henrik asks. If he follows orders, Mark will be rewarded with a family. If he doesn’t, he will be cruelly punished. Four episodes ago Mark was a stone-faced menace chasing Sarah through a diner. Tonight I smiled when he nervously kissed Gracie on the cheek. He’s still a murderous lackey, but he’s also a nervous young man with a crush. Trying to rectify the two sides of that coin makes for very compelling television.
Over on the Neolutionist side of things, Leekie also gets a big dose of humanity. The idea of Leekie as a parental figure for the clones has largely been left on the backburner since he was first introduced in season one. It comes back in a big way tonight. He trusts Cosima with the truth: the Dyad Institute lost the original genome so they are flying blind when it comes to the clones. He also agrees to continue Cosima’s treatment against Rachel’s explicit orders. Leekie’s rewarded for his fatherly concern with a visit from Sarah. She’s discovered that one of the original clone creators—Rachel’s adoptive father aka “Swan Man”— may still be alive. If he is, that will give Dyad a big leg up on reconstructing the original genome. Whether or not this softer side of Leekie is an act is still up in the air. For the moment, however, his willingness to disobey orders and help Cosima earns Sarah’s uneasy trust. It also adds some layers to his character beyond “Dyad minion” or “manipulative scientist.”
When Orphan Black first premiered it seemed like a show tailor made to discuss nature vs. nurture. The idea of identical clones living less-than identical lives could open up a wealth of discussion about the factors that shape identity. Interestingly, that hasn’t been a particularly explicit theme so far. Sure Alison, Cosima, and Sarah took divergent paths in life, but the show has been less interested in exploring the nature or nurture that guided them along the way.
Tonight, however, nature vs. nurture comes up in a big way through Rachel and Helena. They are the two most explicitly “evil” clones: women who are willing to use any means necessary to achieve their ends and show no remorse for their actions. But just how did they turn out so differently from Sarah, Alison, and Cosima?
It’s all about how they were raised. Helena spent her childhood with nuns who were convinced she was a demon; her teenage years with abusive Tomas; and her adulthood sleeping on the floor of a storage locker. After getting shot by her sister, she was kidnapped, drugged, and forced to marry a creepy cult leader who then stole one of her eggs. Helena’s lived a life full of abuse and almost completely absent of affection. It’s no wonder she became an unstable killer.
Rachel, on the other hand, was raised with a different emotional burden. She’s been aware of her clone status since she was a child. While she claims this is a “privilege,” it’s easy to see it as a burden as well. Once her adoptive parents were killed in a lab accident, she was raised directly by the Dyad Institute and Dr. Leekie. Throughout her entire life she’s known that the people who love her most—her parents, boyfriends, and mentors—are also monitoring her every move as part of a science project. It’s an unbearable reality, and Rachel has learned to rigidly compartmentalize her life in order to regain some sense of control
That goes a long way to contextualizing tonight’s disturbing sex scene. She orders Paul around like a dog, pours him a glass of wine she won’t let him drink, and slaps him when he makes a move to engage with her. By dominating the man who is reporting on her, Rachel gives herself the facade of power. There’s a strong argument to be made that what Rachel is doing is rape. It’s certainly sexual coercion. That’s reprehensible on every level; and yet again it’s also understandable. Rachel demands absolute control in her sex life because she has virtually no control over the rest of her life. That again puts the viewer in a tricky position of condemning a character’s actions while sympathizing with her motivations.
But perhaps not all is lost for the show’s “villains.” Helena is a product of her environment, but once her environment changes, she begins to change as well. Now that she’s got Sarah, Felix, and Art looking out for her, Helena starts acting a little differently. She listens when Sarah asks her to respect Felix (“That’s my brother, which means he’s one of our sisters.”), she ties up Art instead of killing him, and she agrees not to shoot Rachel once Sarah shows her some genuine sisterly affection. At the end of season one Sarah decided Helena was too far-gone to be saved. Now that she’s been given a second chance with her seestra, Sarah’s trying rehabilitation rather than violence. It just might be working.
We’re halfway through season two and this episode lays a lot of groundwork for the main threads of the second half of the season: Helena and Sarah team up to find Swan Man while the Proletheans and Neolutionists—both suffering from some dissent in the ranks—hunt them down. Yet even with all of these swirling plot threads, Orphan Black never looses sight of its characters. Now that we’ve gotten to know Mark, Helena, Rachel, and Leekie it’s harder to hope for their demise. The line between heroes and villains is irreparably blurred. Orphan Black is all the better for it.
Clone Club Conversations
- No Alison this week and Paul is back. Ugh.
- Tonight’s title “Ipsa Scientia Potestas Est” translates to “knowledge itself is power.” Like all of this season’s titles, it’s a quote from Sir Francis Bacon.
- Felix gets to star in a sexy rom com for about three minutes before Paul shows up to ruin it all. Dyad now has a murder weapon with Felix’s fingerprints on it to use as leverage against Sarah. But for now let’s just focus on that delightful Tears For Fears-scored montage of Felix getting ready for a date with the coroner from season one!
- She’s barely in this episode, but this might be the best Kira week yet. She finally starts to show some frustration with Sarah’s constant abandonment, and she helps Cal placate a nosey police officer. Skyler Wexler is a really fantastic child actress.
- Cal has a gun, a fake ID, and a ton of cash tucked away in his unregistered RV. If Cal turns out to be evil I will cry for days.
- 10 points to Gyffindor for Art’s “WTF?” face as Helena and Sarah walk off arm-in-arm.
- “Helena, don’t jump out and scare us with an axe or some shit.”
Singer Bonnie Tyler will perform her 1983 hit “Total Eclipse of the Heart” on Royal Caribbean’s Total Eclipse Cruise, a cruise ship that will be in the path of the total solar eclipse come Monday. Tyler will take time off her world tour to belt out the power ballad — just as the moon crosses […]
In honor of the great director Jonathan Demme who died yesterday, please enjoy this bloopers reel from his classic film Silence of the Lambs. More horror film blooper reels at TVOvermind.
“Quid pro quo – I tell you things, you tell me things.” Edited by Jon Tomlinson; Narration: Andy Geller; Executive Producer: Dustin McLean (CineFix)
Toaster ovens are the perfect appliance for small things like toasted sandwiches and roasted garlic (try it!), but anything more involved usually requires a full-sized conventional oven.However, despite its small size, the Wolfgang Puck Pressure Oven can handle anything from baked pastries to broiled meats. This kitchen appliance has a minimal countertop footprint, and cooks […]
The Pry.Me Bottle Opener holds tens of thousands of times its own weight, and you can pick one up now from the Boing Boing Store.This remarkable keychain is considerably smaller than any of your keys, but don’t let that fool you: it can easily open any bottle, and could even tow a trailer full of […]